Possible spoilers ahead!
Disney+’s “The Right Stuff” is based on Tom Wolfe’s novel of the same name, and is the second adaptation behind Philip Kaufman’s 1983 film. This take on “The Right Stuff” ditches the all the lead up to manned spaceflight (like Sputnik and the bravery of early test pilots like Chuck Yeager) and takes us right to 1959, right at the start of American’s space race against the Soviet Union.
The first episode finds uptight pre-NASA officials working on a list of the nation’s best pilots who will (if all goes well) become the vaunted Mercury Seven. All the candidates have the right stuff in the air, but on the ground, it’s an endless world of booze and extramarital affairs. Right from the start, the series goes out of its way to make Navy pilot Alan B. Shepard (Jake McDorman) a complete asshole. How accurate this is I don’t know, the only comparison I can make is the Alan Shepard from HBO’s “From the Earth to the Moon,” but that version was angry at being unable to fly due to an ear condition.
But the Alan Shepard in Disney’s “The Right Stuff” is insane with anger and running on a tank full of pent-up anxiety. He constantly cheats on his wife and is hated by most of his colleagues. Shepard’s biggest rival is Marine pilot John Glenn (Patrick J. Adams), who is a family fan and treats others with respect. Meanwhile, there’s bad blood between Gordon Cooper (Colin O’Donoghue) and decorated veteran Gus Grissom (Michael Trotter). The other three Mercury astronauts (including “Mad Men’s” Aaron Staton) are basically just there to round out the Mercury Seven.
For me, the most interesting aspect of the show is the wives of the astronauts. Granted, the lives of these women have been portrayed in movies and TV shows before, but it’s always interesting to learn how things at home were going. As Life magazine shared with the world upbeat fairy tales of domestic bliss and of how loyal their husbands were, these remarkable women had to deal with the pain and anxiety that came with their husband’s job. And they often had nobody to talk to other than each other.
In the Disney series, the standouts in the wive’s club are Eloise Mumford as Trudy Cooper (who agrees to reunite with her estranged husband to improve his chances of being selected tot he astronaut program); Nora Zehetner as Annie Glenn (who has to bravely face the media onslaught even though she speaks with a stutter); and Shannon Lucio as Louise Shepard (who must cope with her husband’s emotional issues and his constant affairs).
The other actors do their best to overcome the weaknesses in the scripts. I think the most likable of the astronauts is Patrick J. Adams as JohnGlenn. Not only is he the nicest of the seven, but he’s also the first one who realizes what they are about to do is historic but also the most dangerous thing man has ever done. I was not a fan of Alan Shepard, but that’s how the character is written and it’s not the fault of actor Jake McDorman. I can’t recall if Shepard was acted like this in the book or in the 1983 movie, or in real life for that matter. All I know is he’s basically the show’s villain and I’m not sure that’s necessary.
Since the series has eight hours to work with I think “The Right Stuff” should have expanded on the book and the story of America’s first astronaut. If I’d had a say I would have made sure the series mentioned some of what we saw in “Hidden Figures.” Maybe even tell the stories of some of the countless other people who made it possible for the United States to send men into space. And maybe the show will explore some of this in future episodes, but somehow I doubt it.
It’s now 60 years since the selection of the Mercury Seven, and all of them are now gone. Tom Wolfe and many of the key people of this era are gone too. Only they would know if anything in the new Disney+ series is accurate or not. In the end, this show is about an important part of American history that’s just as thrilling now as it was in the 60s. The problem is, it’s been done before and it’s been done better.
“The Right Stuff” grade: C