Possible spoilers ahead!
The new Apple TV series “Physical” follows the story of housewife Sheila Rubins (Rose Byrne) who seems to be having a mid-life crisis. It’s 1981 and her life seems stuck in neutral as her values of peace and love seem pointless with Regan now in the White House. She now thinks her failed academic husband, Danny (Rory Scovel) is a loser, and instead of eating “clean, healthy foods” Sheila binges on fast food only to throw it back up. All hope seems lost for poor Sheila, until one day when she discovers that 80s sensation called aerobics.
“Physical” is one strange show because it deals with some heavy topics, but it seems to want to make it funny, but the problem is none of this is funny. A man or a woman with an eating disorder is no laughing matter, if anything it is a topic that demands to be treated with care and respect. This show doesn’t try to do that, instead “Physical” treats Sheila’s disorder as if it’s just something she does now and then, but in the first episode we see this is a daily routine for her. And no, just because she goes to ballet class afterward does not make it okay.
It might have helped if Sheila was a sympathetic character or someone the audience can get behind. But based on the episodes Apple has released so far, Sheila is neither of those things. As far as I can tell, Sheila is an Olympic-level self-loather who hates everyone and everything. Through the series, she judges every man and woman she comes across for being heavier than she is, prettier, uglier, more successful, or whatever else comes into her mind. And almost immediately, she judges herself for being so superficial.
The reason I know all of this about her is that in every scene of the show Sheila narrates her inner thoughts. Let me be clear: this isn’t just done at the beginning of the episode or the end. It’s done in every damn scene! “Physical” has so much narration that at times I wasn’t sure whether to listen to Sheila or if I should pay attention to whatever was on the screen at the time.
Oh but there’s more: Sheila pretends she’s someone else whenever her self-involved husband is around, then gets mad at him for not knowing her better. Hager’s husband is an idiot for sure, but he’s not a mind reader and couldn’t possibly know what’s his wife is going through. Another annoying habit is how she constantly twists anything her husband or other people say to her into an insult towards her.
However, all the problems I have with the character of Sheila have nothing to do with Rose Byrne. The actress does a good job for the most part, and there are moments during the show where she shines like during a conversation with one of her husband’s students. All the problem I have come from the scripts, and the way it handles some very serious issues.
As for the supporting cast, I’ve already mentioned Rory Scovel as Sheila’s husband, but there’s also Bunny (Della Saba). She’s the owner of the financially struggling aerobics studio where Sheila discover her new addiction. Bunny lives at the studio with her part-time pornographer, full-time surfer boyfriend Tyler (a soulful Lou Taylor Pucci). Then there’s Greta (Deirdre Friel), a fellow mom at Sheila’s daughter’s daycare who’s revealed to be the wife of Danny’s biggest political donor (Ian Gomez). They’re all fine I guess, but I had to choose one I think Bunny has the most potential.
As you can probably tell, I was pretty disappointed with “Physical.” I don’t like how the series tries to make eating disorders funny, or how narcissistic Sheila is. Maybe the show would have worked better if it had been a flat drama. Since a lot of the conflict is built around Sheila and Danny’s marriage, so the drama angle would have made more sense. I watched all the episodes Apple made available, but I didn’t see anything that would make me want to come back for more.
“Physical” final grade: D